September 14, 2023

Best Wood for Mallets: A Comprehensive Guide

A mallet is a hammer-like tool used for driving nails or breaking objects. When choosing wood for your mallet, could you pay attention to its density? Dense, tough hardwoods can better withstand the shock of each blow.

Regarding toughness, the Janka rating of wood measures how many pounds of force it takes to dent a piece of wood. This is a quick way to check the compressive strength of a wood species.

Wooden mallets weigh between 2lbs to 3lbs. This post contains popular, affordable hardwoods for making wooden mallets. You will also learn why dense hardwoods are better for making mallets. In this article, you discover how heavy your handmade wooden mallet should be.

Characteristics of Wood for Mallets

Hardness and density

Dense tough hardwoods do a better job of handling the jarring impact of each knock. It does not splinter easily. An increase in density leads to an increase in that wood type’s average dried weight. Hard-dense timbers are also heavier. You may go for White Oak, Hard Maple, and Beechwood.

The Janka hardness scale measures the force needed to push a steel ball into wood until it falls out and back in again. That indicates how well the wood holds nails or other types of screws. The higher the number, the more brittle and less tough it becomes.

Shock resistance

Wood for Mallets makes lightweight, heavy-duty rubber mallets with replaceable rubber heads. You can use this petite-headed mallet at all times. Its interchangeable hammerhead has interchangeable faces. The small rubber mallet has a perfect rubber handle, and it is ergonomically designed, which is anti-slip, comfortable to hold, suitable for long-term use, and can reduce fatigue. The wood also acts as a shock absorber. It takes much of the impact.

Durability

Mallets should be durable enough to withstand the rigorous environments of the front ensemble. 

Availability

When looking for wood for mallets, pick readily available wood. Some species grow slowly, hence the unavailability. 

Types of Wood for Mallets

Hardwoods:

Softwoods:

Choosing the Best Wood for Your Mallet

  • Intended use
  • Personal preference
  • Budget
  • Availability
  • Hardwoods for Mallets

Maple

Characteristics

Maple is a lighter wood with a smoother grain, making it ideal for delicate work like striking with chisels or using precision instruments. Hard maple is the best, but soft maple still performs well. However,  it is a bit softer than sugar maple. Mallets are burled hardwoods that are very resistant to splitting and chipping. Fine.

Advantages

  • Durable
  • Large size and end grain striking surfaces
  • Softer
  • Resistant to splitting

Disadvantages

  • A bit softer

Best use cases

They are ideal for pounding nails or making metal.

Examples of mallets made from maple

  • Thor’s Hammer
  • UJ Ramelson Rock Maple Mallet

Oak

Characteristics

Oak is another wood used for heavy and light tasking, based on the oak. Red oak is a popular choice for making mallets. Its end-grain striking surface makes it large and durable. However, it is not the most appealing in appearance, but it gets your job done quite effectively.

Advantages

  • It is for both heavy and light tasking
  • Large
  • Durable
  • Effective

Disadvantages

  • Not quite appealing 

Best use cases

  • Tapping chisels 
  • Adjusting the blade of a plane

Examples of mallets made from oak

  • Wooden Dead Blow Mallet
  • Bull Oak mallet

Hickory

Characteristics

Hickory is one of the most popular types of wood for making mallets. Hickory, however, is not as good at holding up with a handle because its heavy weight makes it break too easily. Hickory has excellent durability and shock absorption abilities and remains lightweight compared to other hardwoods like ash or oak. 

Walnut protects against impacts if treated with oils or linseed oil finishing before being used as a wooden mallet head. Hickory is a solid, dense wood for heavy-duty applications like frames or sledgehammers.

Advantages

  • Excellent durability 
  • Lightweight compared to other hardwoods
  • Shock absorption abilities
  • It holds up well against impacts
  • Accept oil finishing

Disadvantages

  • Breaks easily
  • Heavyweight

Best use cases

  • Woodworking
  • Carpentry

Examples of mallets made from hickory

  • DICTUM Square Mallet with Treated Hickory Handle, 600g
  • CS Osborne Hickory Mallet ~ Barrel-Shaped Head

Ash

Characteristics

Ash, like Walnut and Maple, is a hardwood but not too hard. It makes a beautiful hammer, but it may be harder to find. Ash mallets are ideal for furniture making, general woodworking, timber framing, and upholstery.

Advantages

  • Beautiful 
  • Versatile 
  • Hard
  • Durable 

Disadvantages

  • Not too much hard

Best use cases

  • Timber framing
  • Upholstery 

Examples of mallets made from ash

  • Handmade Maple & Ash Wood Mallet
  • Croquet mallet

Walnut

Just like maple, walnut ensures long-term durability. All mallets are fitted with mortise and tenon with a wedge driven through the top to ensure a tight fit. The wedge can protrude or be cut off flat for whichever look you want.

Advantages

  • Beautiful
  • Handcraft able
  • Durable 
  • Dependable

Disadvantages

  • It produces too much bounce

Best use cases

  • Ideal for personal use

Examples of mallets made from walnut

  • Thor’s Hammer Mjolnir
  • Clay beech mallet

Softwoods for Mallets

Pine

A mallet made from softwood such as White Pine would not last very long. It would take just as much damage as what you were striking. Pine is easier to work, but being softer means it will suffer damage easier when you bash it.

Advantages

  • Last long
  • Easier to work with
  • Softer
  • Beautiful 

Disadvantages

  • Suffer damage easier

Best use cases

  • Driving the chisel into the wood.
  • Tapping furniture

Examples of mallets made from pine

  • ApudArmis 32In Six Player Croquet Set
  • Croquet mallets

Fir

Fir trees grow quickly and have less lignin. It is lightweight but does not last as long. Hit a soft wooden surface with this hammer. That is the best option because this mallet will not cause any damage to the surface.

Advantages

  • Lightweight
  • Soft
  • No damage
  • Ideal for leather surfaces

Disadvantages

  • It does not last long

Best use cases

  • Wood stores
  • Roofs

Examples of mallets made from fir

  • Pair Glockenspiel Mallets 
  • Percussion mallets

Comparison of Hardwoods and Softwoods for Mallets

Hardwoods and softwoods are two of the best types of wood for making wooden mallets. They have both their advantages and disadvantages. Softwoods come from evergreen trees (such as pines) and are softer than hardwoods because they grow faster due to the faster cell division of these trees. Softwoods are best suited for making a bat for pushing and pulling because they flex more than hardwoods.

Pros

  • Grows quickly 
  • Availability
  • Lightweight
  • No damage on soft surfaces

Cons

  • They do not last long
  • Not for hardwood

Hardwoods grow at a slower rate but are denser and last longer. Growth is slowed by cold weather or dry conditions, meaning there is less water pressure on the cells during tree growth, making them tougher when compared to softwood trees. 

For your mallet head or handle material to be easier on your hands while hammering. Opt for lightweight softwood such as white pine. If you need some strength in your mallet, opt for hardwoods like maple or oak which are heavier and denser than their softer counterparts.

Pros

  • Durable
  • Powerful hammering
  • It does not break easily
  • Also for light duty

Cons

  • Grow slowly 
  • Heavier 

Other Factors to Consider When Choosing Wood for Mallets

Wood grain orientation

Pay attention to the wood grain direction. Grain direction refers to the trunk’s longitudinal, or vertical, axis, along which the structural cells are elongated. It affects long-term weathering.

Moisture content

The moisture content of wood varies between 8% and 25% by weight, depending on the relative humidity of the air. Moisture content can cause the wood to shrink and then expand. There will always be seasonal changes, but nothing changes when the moisture content is good. 

Wood finish

Wood finishes such as paint, varnish, and stain give a desired appearance, protect wood surfaces, and provide a cleanable surface. 

Conclusion

Your choice is not limited to a particular material. Most hardwoods can be used to make mallets, but they should be hard enough to be used as mallets. Any wood in the 1000 Janka hardness range will do. Which wood is best for your mallet also depends on the availability of the species in your region.

If you are looking for a mallet with a nice view, opt for birch. For longevity, lignum vitae is the best. If you are on a tight budget, go for hard maple. Also consider the material that better suits your surface.

FAQs

What is the best wood for a carving mallet?

The best wood for a carving mallet is typically hardwood, with options like maple or oak being popular choices. Hardwoods are favored for mallet construction due to their ability to endure the repeated impacts of carving, ensuring a long-lasting and durable tool. It’s important to highlight that softwoods are unsuitable for crafting wooden mallets because they lack the durability required for carving tasks and are prone to splintering.

Can you make a mallet out of any type of wood?

No, not any wood is suitable for making a mallet. Some woods lack the required durability, risking splintering or breaking during woodworking tasks. Wood choice is critical for a reliable mallet.

Is it better to use hardwood or softwood for a mallet?

Choose hardwood for mallets because it’s more durable than softwood, enduring woodworking impacts and stresses, ensuring a sturdy, long-lasting tool.

What is the difference between hardwood and softwood?

Hardwood comes from deciduous trees that shed leaves annually, while softwood comes from evergreen conifers. These tree distinctions impact wood characteristics, like density and grain patterns, influencing their usability in construction and woodworking.

How do I know if a piece of wood is suitable for making a mallet?

To assess wood for a mallet, check its hardness and density. It must resist splintering on impact for safety and durability during woodworking.

Can I use reclaimed wood to make a mallet?

Yes, reclaimed wood is suitable for making a mallet, but consider the wood’s thickness for adequate strength and durability to withstand woodworking tasks.

What is the ideal weight for a mallet?

Choose between 2lb 12oz to 3lb 4oz for an ideal mallet weight. This range balances force and comfortable control for woodworking. Your specific preference may vary based on your tasks.

How long should a wooden mallet last?

A wooden mallet typically lasts 20 to 30 years, but this can vary based on factors like wood quality, frequency of use, care, and tasks performed. Properly maintained, high-quality mallets can exceed 30 years, while heavy, neglected use may shorten their lifespan.

Should I oil my wooden mallet?

Oiling your wooden mallet is recommended. It enhances usability and durability and guards against moisture absorption, helping maintain its condition and lifespan. The oil nourishes the wood, preventing drying and potential cracks and ensuring reliability. The oil creates a protective barrier, reducing moisture damage and environmental wear.

How do I care for my wooden mallet to ensure it lasts?

Caring for your wooden mallet to ensure its longevity involves more than just regular oiling and proper storage. Let’s explore the specifics.

Oiling:

  • Use food-grade mineral oil or specific wood conditioning oils; avoid vegetable oils or anything that can turn rancid.
  • Apply a thin, even coat of oil to the entire mallet’s surface using a clean cloth or brush.
  • Allow the oil to penetrate the wood for a few hours or overnight before removing excess.

Proper Storage:

  • Store it in a tool rack or a dedicated space away from extreme temperature fluctuations or moisture.
  • Avoid prolonged exposure to direct sunlight, as it can cause wood warping or cracking.
  • Consider covering your mallet with a cloth or storing it in a protective case to prevent dust and debris buildup.

Regular Cleaning:

  • After use, wipe it down with a clean, dry cloth to remove dust or debris.
  • For stubborn dirt, use a damp cloth with mild soap solution, ensuring thorough drying afterward.

Handle with Care:

  • Avoid striking hard or metal surfaces to prevent splintering or damage.
  • Use the mallet for its intended purpose and avoid excessive force.

Inspect for Damage:

  • Periodically check for cracks, splinters, or loose parts, especially around the head and handle.
  • Address any damage promptly by sanding rough spots or applying wood filler as needed.

Following these care guidelines ensures your wooden mallet remains in excellent condition, serving you well for years. Regular maintenance and proper handling extend its lifespan and maintain its effectiveness in woodworking projects.

David D. Hughes

Leave a Reply